Windows 11 "Government Edition" is Microsoft's anti-bloatware nightmare

zohaibahd

Posts: 233   +5
Staff
In context: If you've been spending time on tech Twitter lately, you may have spotted chatter about a mysterious "Windows 11 Government Edition" that's been making the rounds. This pared-down, unofficial version of Microsoft's OS started turning heads last week after a user dropped some screenshots showing off the Windows build of our dreams.

Sadly, this Windows build has nothing to do with the government nor Microsoft. It's actually an unsanctioned, heavily modified version of Windows 11 that strips out a bunch of standard components. The storage footprint is dramatically reduced by removing bundled apps like Microsoft Edge, the Windows Security suite, multimedia tools like Camera and Media Player, and even simple utilities like Paint and Clock.

Aside from core file management with Explorer, the only pre-installed apps are Settings, Backup, and a few other WindowsTools utilities. Even the Start menu is barren, displaying no apps whatsoever. Moreover, installing new programs could prove tricky for some since there's no Microsoft Store.

Perhaps the most intriguing tweak is that the build appears to bypass Windows 11's strict hardware requirements. Microsoft's official release mandates relatively modern CPU, RAM, storage and security specs that have precluded millions of PCs from upgrading. But this unofficial version can reportedly run on older systems that fall short of those standards.

Based on screenshots, the barebones OS keeps RAM usage to around 1.2GB on a 4GB system with nothing else open – lean enough that Chrome might actually be usable with more than 3 measly tabs on such specs.

While the "Government Edition" name suggests an official distribution from Microsoft, all signs point to this being a community project along the same lines as "Tiny11" and other hacked Windows rebuilds. After all, it would be highly unlikely for the company to release an official build without Defender or Edge – two products they've been aggressively pushing on users for years.

Also, it's best to avoid these builds since downloading them would require going through unofficial channels and likely using dubious activation workarounds.

That's not to say official government builds don't exist. Back in 2017, Microsoft announced the Windows 10 China Government Edition, which was supposedly slimmer than regular Windows versions. For instance, it ditched OneDrive since it wasn't "needed by Chinese government employees."

That said, the sheer interest in such builds alone highlights rising frustrations with Windows 11's incessant advertising and bloat. Microsoft has taken an increasingly aggressive approach to monetizing its OS of late, stuffing ads into core user experiences like the Start menu and Settings apps.

It'll be interesting to see if Redmond takes any cues from the grassroots interest and offers a more spartan, official "Lean" edition down the line, maybe something like the ill-fated Windows 10X?

Permalink to story:

 
So, tell me again, why is a random hacked and pirated reduced OS image with a misleading name (like if it would be something the "government" would use) newsworthy, especially since the creator of tiny11 has released tiny11builder months ago, with which anyone can create their own reduced OS image, in a completely legal way, and which was also most likely used to generate this particular random pirated image?
 
So, tell me again, why is a random hacked and pirated reduced OS image with a misleading name (like if it would be something the "government" would use) newsworthy, especially since the creator of tiny11 has released tiny11builder months ago, with which anyone can create their own reduced OS image, in a completely legal way, and which was also most likely used to generate this particular random pirated image?
It's for Microsoft hate train ticket holders.
 
No kidding, my W11 takes around 4-6GB when I dont even do anything. I turn off all the store apps, I remove alot of other stuff that auto start... and still. 4.5GB of use. Id love to have this version of Windows!
 
Windows 11 Enterprise is probably the next best thing at the moment, can disable telemetry and a bunch of other unwanted.
Windows 11 Enterprise is Windows 10 Pro with some additional features. The telemetry and a bunch of other unwanted stuff can easily be be disabled in any version Windows 11 if you know what you are doing.
 
I've been using customised answer files when installing Windows to cut out the cruft during installation.

No messing around with the original Windows image required. Generate an answer file by using using the excellent online tool at https://schneegans.de/windows/unattend-generator/

An autounattend.xml file can be used on a USB stick by putting the file on it's root.

We've even incorporated answer files generated here into our MDT server at work for mass imaging our domain computers.

So simple and elegant, it's a wonder more people don't know about it.
 
Sounds too good to be true. I like to hear more about it.
Is there any spyware in it?
where can it be downloaded?
 
I like to encourage modding. Assuming anything not directly from Microsoft is dodgey or "illegal" is just FUD marketing by Microsoft that has captured too many people.

I've tried a few of these tiny releases and they appeared optimized for gaming but in any event wouldn't run my remaining Windows program (I've gone Linux, but still have a Windows pro retail license).

I see all this as fair use and even right to repair. Do your research before downloading anything, even from a Microsoft site as it could contain malware such as data collection, ad insertion, trojan updates that change the character of the software, bugs that destroy your data, and just low quality in general.
 
Back