Rogue otters and vicious letterboxes: on the campaign trail in the Outer Hebrides

The remote Scottish constituency has all Britain’s problems but worse

Road warning signpost showing a silhouette image of an otter and text underneath reading Caution Otters Crossing

By Georgia Banjo

Torcuil Crichton, the Labour candidate hoping to win the Western Isles from the Scottish National Party (SNP), leant against his red Mini and polished off a packet of prawn-cocktail crisps. “Wee red car, big red change”, read a sign on the window. An island boy, he had grown up near Stornoway, the largest town in the Outer Hebrides. His portfolio career had included a spell as a screenwriter – he once wrote a drama for Gaelic TV about a teenager who had hallucinations of Elvis – and more than a decade as a political journalist in London. Now he was back, with a grey quiff and a tweed jacket, trying to convince voters in the far-flung constituency to choose a Labour government “or drift off into the Atlantic”.

On July 4th a resurgent Scottish Labour Party could strike a blow against the SNP, long the dominant force in Scottish politics. Crichton is running against Angus MacNeil, the charismatic MP of the Western Isles, who was expelled from the SNP last year after claiming the party wasn’t serious about independence. He is standing as an independent, and the SNP has selected its own candidate. With the nationalist vote split, Labour are favourites for the seat MacNeil took from them nearly 20 years ago. Winning will not, however, be straightforward.

Explore more

More from 1843 magazine

1843 magazine | America’s gerontocrats are more radical than they look

A conservative writer argues that his country’s rulers exhibit the vices of youth, not old age

1843 magazine | Canadian Sikhs thought they were safe to protest against India. Then one of them was gunned down

Sikhs campaigning for an independent state believe they are in the Indian government’s sights


1843 magazine | No British election is complete without a man with a bin on his head

Joke candidates reveal the carnival element of British democracy


More from 1843 magazine

1843 magazine | America’s gerontocrats are more radical than they look

A conservative writer argues that his country’s rulers exhibit the vices of youth, not old age

1843 magazine | Canadian Sikhs thought they were safe to protest against India. Then one of them was gunned down

Sikhs campaigning for an independent state believe they are in the Indian government’s sights


1843 magazine | No British election is complete without a man with a bin on his head

Joke candidates reveal the carnival element of British democracy


1843 magazine | “Monkeys with a grenade”: inside the nuclear-power station on Ukraine’s front line

Former employees say the plant is being dangerously mismanaged by the Russians

1843 magazine | Can fasting help you live to 100?

An Italian doctor thinks it can – and he’s got a diet to sell you

1843 magazine | Mad Max in paradise: New Caledonia in turmoil

The political dispute that provoked riots in the idyllic island territory hasn’t gone away