Google apps
Main menu
1 – 4 of 4
Comment deleted

This comment has been removed by the author.

Friday, 11 November, 2011

Blogger Graham MF Greene said...

(Posting as a comment because I am highly unlikely to ever sort out and post my review of this).

"It isn't universal; it hasn't told us anything about Fathers and Sons or War that we didn't already know."

Actually, I think that both you and Simpson underestimate the degree to which that song - while, yes, not entirely universal - resonates with a lot of people in a very specific way.

While it is, of course, a powerful song under it's own steam. The reason that it twists my gut to such an extent that I bawl at folk concerts, and (genuinely) had to take it out of my record collection for a couple of years are more specific. It manages, particularly in the chorus, to sum up so accurately and resurrect so powerfully the experience of being dependant on someone who we might if we were being nice describe as 'chaotic neutral' in a way that nothing I've ever encountered has. The excuse making, the justifications, the slight edge of defensive mythologising; the hint of someone who is possibly avoiding looking under the rock of 'good but hapless' in case of what they find, hits home so hard.

I don't think I've articulated this brilliantly. But in conclusion, that is why the song 'Never Any Good' by Martin Simpson makes me cry like a girl.

yrs,

Graham M.F. Greene (Mrs)

Friday, 11 November, 2011

Anonymous Anonymous said...

hey, I noticed you posted the lyrics "I've been to Gary Indiana, Bethlehem P.A....but the furnace never burned as bright as down East Common Lane" by Martin Simpson, I've been looking for the name of this song for ages. you don't know what it's called do you and if I'd be able to find a copy somewhere?

Tuesday, 01 May, 2012

Blogger Andrew Rilstone said...

Hi,

The song is called "Home Again", and it's on the album "True Stories". Which also has the very lovely "One Day" and his take on the "Cruel Sister" ballad. Hope this helps

Andrew

Tuesday, 01 May, 2012